US Male Major Title Drought Is Not Taylor Fritz's Responsibility to Carry

I have some opinions regarding the remarks delivered by the sports network commentator Chris Fowler after the Serbian champion's victory over the American player in the US Open quarter-finals. Consider – the athlete represents American, Fowler is from the US – and sports often encourage nationalism. A little bit of letdown would have been understandable. Instead, Fowler invoked the ongoing absence of US male players at the majors: not one of them has won a trophy since Andy Roddick in 2003, and he had been the last one standing in the tournament.

Everyone enjoy a storyline, me too. But come on. Even if the American had beaten Djokovic for the initial occasion, phenomenal talent Carlos Alcaraz was looming in the next round, who he has yet to beat in an official match. And had he someway survived that, it would have been title holder Jannik Sinner, against whom the American had dropped 10 of the last 11 sets. Alcaraz and Sinner had also divided the last seven major titles (plus the Spaniard proceeded to thrash a fatigued Djokovic in the subsequent match). He said in press following his defeat that he actually preferred his draw, because it offered the chance to beat the three best competitors in the world in succession. Fritz is more than within his right to aspire to the accomplishment; an competitor is supposed to have faith in themselves. But going into that Serbian quarter-final what other person in their right mind had the lack of American champions on the brain?

The American star's second serve the only thing standing in her way and consistent victories

The American, twenty-eight, is placed fourth in the world entering this week’s year-end championships and has secured his previous six matches over No 3 the German with increasing ease. It's likely he could take that spot for himself in the coming years. But it’s clear that right now, that is as high as he can climb: The Italian and Spaniard lie a vast gap of ranking points away. Fritz’s elite serve and concussive strength on each forehand and backhand are sufficiently enough to defeat most rivals on the professional circuit. When facing the handful of once-in-a-lifetime players, though, he is often helpless. The past few seasons has seen the interesting rise of lanky, towering athletes who can nonetheless cover the court with the alarming speed and fluidity of much shorter men. Fritz is 6ft 5ins and looks it. His footwork is rigid, as if he’s still getting used to his legs. So he’ll rarely steal a point that the other player was dictating, and hitting a soft shot against him is usually a reliable tactic. That serves as a pretty severe limitation on his upside.

Fritz has achieved a several significant, unexpected advancements over the years. Early on of the decade, he was hovering around the bottom of the top 30. Two years after, he was approaching the elite ten. The previous season, he suddenly exploded up to No 4 – and maintained the position. But the next leap, competing against and beating legendary figures like Alcaraz, the Italian, and even a aging Djokovic, is the toughest of all. What could Fowler have been thinking? That Fritz, in 2025, was a serious threat to defeat them all back-to-back? That it was appropriate mentioning the continuing slump of US male players lifting major titles when Fritz had exited the US Open in the quarter-finals? The thirst is simply too much and the appreciation for the difficulty of the challenge insufficient.

Taylor Fritz made a career-best run to the Wimbledon semi-finals in the summer.

Fritz’s play in that very last eight match ought to have been enough of an indication. The Serbian triumphed in four rounds, a victory that only felt uncertain for brief periods towards the very end, when the American had saved a few championship opportunities and had a chance to maintain serve for 5-5. The pair appeared evenly matched during the exchanges, with the American creating numerous chances to win the opponent's serve. But the champion saved service break opportunity after service break opportunity, extending the run to the point of agony. When Fritz eventually did convert one of the chances at 5-5 in the middle stanza, he immediately played a terrible game to lose his own serve again; Djokovic had drawn him into a battle secondary to the main contest and compelled him to expend far too much effort to win it. Down match points in the last game, his first serve floated to the sky. He extended the contest two times on his second serve, but ultimately committed two errors. It wasn’t a collapse, in my opinion, just a consequence of needing to hit too many second serves.

The contest was quite compelling evidence that the American is insufficiently skilled to defeat any form of the Serbian, who lost to Alcaraz in the next round and did not particularly appeared like he believed he could win. This is perfectly fine – Djokovic is the best player ever, and might not be at the height of his athletic abilities anymore, but has developed enough experience and tactical know-how to compensate for quite a bit of the drop-off. The problem is those who were expecting Fritz to win, and putting pressure on him to achieve that, when he was yet to accomplished anything that suggested he would.

The American is an valuable contributor to the tour nonetheless. He’s a patient, thoughtful voice in media sessions, exceeding almost everyone on the men's tour aside from Daniil Medvedev, willing to not just say his emotions or the strategy he felt decided a contest, but clarify it. That he ought to bear the brunt of the responsibility for America not produce a men's grand slam winner since the last American titlist feels unfair. (Now that the fellow American is competing alongside him in the standings, perhaps they can share that load.)

Year-End Championships: Singles Groups

American legend Group

  • Carlos Alcaraz (Sp)
  • Taylor Fritz (US)
  • Alex de Minaur (Aus)
  • The Italian stylist

Swedish icon Division

  • The Italian champion
  • The German powerhouse
  • The rising American
  • The Canadian talent

“I would likely dwell on it forever if I don’t accomplish it,” Fritz informed a journalist in June of claiming a grand slam. I hope he understands that he’s not a failure if he doesn’t fulfill that objective, that breaking through Alcaraz and Sinner’s young, terrifying reign is actually extremely unlikely for all other players. {

David Simon
David Simon

Elena Voss is a freelance writer and cultural critic based in Berlin, specializing in contemporary art and digital culture.